A brief history of resistance to structural adjustment by george caffentzis and silvia federici from the book democratizing the global economy kevin danaher, editor common courage press 2001 in the dozens of countries where the international monetary fund and world bank have imposed structural adjustment programs saps, people have not been. Malawi has been implementing structural adjustment reforms since 1981 in search of a way to revive its declining economic growth triggered by the oil shocks and general world economic recession of the mid and late 1970s. Foreign exchange markets, as part of structural adjustment programs, served to increase the cost of imports and hence reduce import spending. The goal of this study was to investigate how the economic reforms have affected people beyond economics. The conventional structural adjustment approach of the 1980s assumed that a certain degree of inequality would boost economic performance and thus drive growth.
The bretton woods institutions, advocated sap as a condition for borrowing development funds. What explains the success or failure of structural. Development politics publish your bachelors or masters thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay. Describes economic objectives, macroeconomic and structural policies for three year adjustment programs supported by esaf resources, as well as associated. The then ruling united national independence party unip government implemented an imf structural adjustment programme sap between 1983 and 1987. The impact of economic structural adjustment programs esaps. Lessons from structural adjustment programmes and their. Poverty worsened in the 1980s and 1990s than the first decade of postindependence zambia, the country built its own institutions without outside help. Lessons from structural adjustment programs and their effects in africa article pdf available in quarterly, journal of international agriculture 50.
Pdf lessons from structural adjustment programs and. In particular the role played by two interest groupsbusiness, organised labour in supporting or opposing economic reforms will be examined. Using a four year panel of postharvest data, a system of six crops, two variable inputs and three fixed inputs is estimated. Structural adjustment programs saps consist of loans provided by the international monetary fund imf and the world bank wb to countries that experienced economic crises. It describes how saps are being implemented and what results they have produced over the past 20 years. Zambias experience in the 1990s illustrates that, on their own, policy changes will not redress decades of mismanagement, especially when the degree of commitment of the elite remains unaltered. Conditionalities are implemented to ensure that the money lent will be spent in accordance with the overall goals of the loan. Structural adjustment programmes and industrialization. The effects of structural adjustment programs on poverty. By the end of the 1970s, many sub saharan african countries were in serious economic difficulties with high inflation. Lessons from structural adjustment programmes and their effects in africa 59 quarterly journal of international agriculture 50 2011, no. This study examines the impact of structural adjustment policy sap on the welfare of zimbabweans, particularly women and children and draws some parallels with economic policy in the us and its effect on social welfare programs and the poor. The structural adjustment programme has not been able to get zambia out of its cycle of rising foreign debt. The paper argues that economic structural adjustment programs esaps, introduced by the world bank.
In general, adjustment meant liberalising and privatising, although saps were wider in scope in that their developmental aims were highly political. Since zambia embarked on its structural adjustment program in late 1991, much has been accomplished. Zambia, for example, having abandoned a structural adjustment programme in the wake ofthe riots on. What explains the success or failure of structural adjustment programs. Structural adjustment has often been perceived as widening inequality. His research interests center around the multifaceted impact of saps in subsaharan africa. Furthermore, the authors also blame the adjustment policies to have failed to take into account the. How the imfworld bank and structural adjustment programsap. Structural adjustment is the name given to a set of free market economic policy reforms imposed on developing countries by the bretton woods institutions the world bank and international monetary fund imf as a condition for receipt of loans. The conventional structuraladjustment approach of the 1980s assumed that a certain degree of inequality would boost economic performance and thus drive growth. Structural adjustment, gender, and the agricultural sector in zambia. Nature and objectives of structural adjustment programs. To assist african development, structural adjustment programmes saps provided conditional lending thomson, 2010.
The impact of economic structural adjustment programs. An assessment of zambias structural adjustment experience. In 1987 the then president kaunda severed zambias four year old relationship with the imf. By 1982, the real price of copperwas at its lowest for nearly 40 years krumm, 1984, in kelly, 1991. A lot of the poverty and corruption results from these same structural adjustment programs, which then contributes to this brain drain, thus twisting the knife in the back, so to speak, as some of what little is allowed to be spent on health is now lost to the already rich, and the poor have to bear the burden. In order to conclusively determine the net impact, pandey and wheeler show that an encompassing, indepth study is required. The story of structural adjustment programme in nigeria from the perspective of the organized labour nwagbara, eucharia nwabugo, ph. Zambia particularly in the field of gemstone and industrial mineral, which offer great potential.
Often structural adjustment has led to spending cuts on important welfare services such as education and health care. Did structural adjustment programmes assist african. The structural adjustment programs saps are created with the goal of reducing the borrowing countrys fiscal imbalances. The latter two kinds of operations are concessional for lowincome countries. The impact of structural adjustment programmes on zimbabwes public health sector a case study tsitsi muvunzi masters thesis politics international politics topic. The second section will discuss the politics of structural adjustment in zambia.
Structural adjustment programs in zimbabwe discussion ethical issues five main criticisms of imf developed countries hold power over undeveloped countries due to western bias towards capitalism of world economy. Consistent implementation of a structural adjustment programme. Structural adjustment programs have been widely blamed for weakening zambia and diminishing its capacity to lift itself and its citizens out of poverty world bank, 2000. The impact of structural adjustment policies saps on. Pdf lessons from structural adjustment programs and their. Structural adjustment, gender, and the agricultural sector in zambia volume 30 issue 1 gisela geisler. Describes economic objectives, macroeconomic and structural policies for threeyear adjustment programs supported by esaf resources, as well as associated. Zambia s experience in the 1990s illustrates that, on their own, policy changes will not redress decades of mismanagement, especially when the degree of commitment of the elite remains unaltered. The economy has been liberalized, and the macroeconomic situation has improved considerably. D department of sociology university of calabar email.
Newsrescue below is a brief background of the events that led many countries to accept saps. The impact of structural adjustment programmes in africa. Coupled with the dwindling income from zambias exports was the rise in the prices of oil imports. Imf employees share capitalist ideals operates under the assumption. When zambia embarked on a structural adjustment program sap in 1992, there was tremendous hope for an economic turnaround. Structural adjustmenta major cause of poverty global issues. World bank adjustment lending in cludes structural adjustment loans, sectoral structural adjustment loans, imf and world bank structural adjustment programs and.
Progress along the path of adjustment and structural reform has not always been steady and macroeconomic management has sometimes faltered but there can be no question that, on the threshold of the 21st century, zambia is much better positioned to move forward on an accelerated growth path than at any time in the previous quarter century. We approach this work with two hypotheses, not mutually exclusive. The latter term became more current in the aftermath ofgrowing popular resistance to the implementation of the former. The article highlights the remaining knowledge gaps with respect to input subsidy targeting and effects in zambia. The impact of structural adjustment programs saps on the performance of sub saharan africa ssa has been deeply investigated and, despite what the international monetary fund imf and the world bank claimed, adjustment policies have often had a negative impact on the poorest and most vulnerable sections of the regions population. The effects of structural adjustment products cut across a number of sectors in the kenyan society, however this paper will focus on the effects of structural adjustment programs on education, health, agriculture, and politics. Structural adjustment programmes saps consist of loans provided by the international monetary fund imf and the world bank wb to countries that. The implications of fem in african countries are especially harsh. Structural adjustment and the debt crisis saps were born as a result. Jan 31, 2012 conditionalities are implemented to ensure that the money lent will be spent in accordance with the overall goals of the loan.
After independence, kenya had been making remarkable progress in the education sector. Doc impacts of saps on zambia obert hagwena academia. Zimbabwe structural adjustment programs by katie beyer on prezi. Despite these measures, zambia had negative economic growth between 1991 and 1995. Pdf the political economy of policy failure in zambia. Agriculture, fishery and forestry, which account for 20 per cent of zambian gdp, shrunk by 2. Lesotho, tanzania, and zambia showed major improvements in their fiscal. The impact of the structural adjustment programmes on. Oberdabernig abstract the focus of this work is to measure the effects of structural adjustment programs saps of the international monetary fund imf on poverty and income distribution.
Did structural adjustment programmes assist african development. Ecomomic policy and development issues, particularly structural adjustment programmes saps have dominated african womens concerns because they have been implicated in the rise of poverty, especially of women, in africa. This article also gives a short analysis of the roles of the world bank, the imf and the local political elites in this process. In march 1992 he organized and directed zambia s first ever national conference on that countrys structural adjustment program. Agricultural production before and during structural adjustment programs saps 5. May 26, 2009 newsrescue below is a brief background of the events that led many countries to accept saps. Evolution of structural adjustment policies in zambia, 19831991 zambia adopted a systematic structural adjustment programme. The major areas of focus in the saps have included the liberalisation of the agricultural sector which centred on price decontrols, market liberalisation, and the repealing of the special crops act, parastatal. Both malawi and zambia had the same population growth rate at 3. Poverty reduction strategy papers prsps zambia enhanced structural adjustment facility policy framework paper, 19992001 prepared by the zambian authorities in collaboration with the staffs of the fund and the world bank march 10, 1999. Structural adjustment programmes saps or economic recovery programmes erps are similar in their essential components.
The effect of structural adjustment programmes on the delivery of veterinary services in africa 3 officially recognized as part of the animal health delivery system. How the imfworld bank and structural adjustment program. The indirect impact of this instrument affects all sectors of any economy in which it operates. These structural reforms were meant to liberalise the economy, broaden and diversify the production base towards nonprimary products and allocate resources. Jan, 2015 to assist african development, structural adjustment programmes saps provided conditional lending thomson, 2010. In order to conclusively determine the net impact, pandey and wheeler show that an encompassing, in depth study is required. Hope has since turned into despair and disillusionment for most people. The bank from which a borrowing country receives its loan depends upon the type of necessity.
April 1998 not for citation without permission of the authors david dollar and jakob svensson macroeconomics and growth group, the world bank the findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed in this paper are entirely those of the authors. However, adjustment programmes tend to concentrate on expenditure reduction policies, thereby hampering the necessary diversification. Structural adjustment definition and criticisms economics. Education under structural adjustment per cent of the government annual expenditure being used to support the mining industry kelly, 1991. Shortcomings and weaknesses of the structuraladjustment. Zambias 19921994 structural adjustment program sciencedirect. Konaduagyemang, imf and world bank sponsored structural adjustment programs in africa, 28. Economic growth and intraregional trade from independence to structural adjustment programs 2 2.
What explains the success or failure of structural adjustment. The goal of this study was to investigate how the economic reforms have affected people beyond. The impact of structural adjustment on food production in zambia. The effects of structural adjustment programs on poverty and. Brief history of resistance to structural adjustment. While giving partial evidence of individual incentives, the aforementioned study shows that great inequality actually inhibits growth. Compared to many other southern african countries, zambia has relatively abundant land and water. Zambia abandoned the stewardship of ibrd and imf structural adjustment programs and chose to seek an accommodation to economic. Structural adjustment programmes saps that were wholly externally driven. Zambia, for example, having abandoned a structural adjustment programme in the wake ofthe riots on the copper. Unfortunately, these programs have impacted the zambian mining industry significantly and.
Chapter 3 structural adjustment and poverty malawi has implemented a series of structural adjustment programmes saps. The key ingredients of structural adjustment programmes are based on an economic model of private ownership, competitive markets and. The impact of structural adjustment on food production in. Structural adjustment and diversification in zambia wiley online. The impact of structural adjustment programmes on zimbabwes. Structural adjustment and diversification in zambia fons meijer development economics and planning department, netherlands economic institute, po box 4175, 3006ad rotterdam, the netherlands, has done research in zambia about the feasibility of producing copper semi. It should however be pointed out that, as the questionnaire was sent only to the heads of the state veterinary services, the private sector point of view has not been taken into account, a fact whi ch may have introduced a bias into the analysis.
Jan 22, 2020 often structural adjustment has led to spending cuts on important welfare services such as education and health care. World bank adjustment lending includes structural adjustment loans, sectoral structural adjustment loans, imf and world bank structural adjustment programs and. Are the imf and the world bank, via their structural adjustment programmes in the. According to zambia industrial and mining corporation zambia cooperative federation zimcos. The two bretton woods institutions require borrowing countries to implement certain policies in order to obtain new loans or to lower interest rates on existing ones. Konaduagyemang, imf and world bank sponsored structural adjustment programs in africa, 27. Structural adjustment and diversification in zambia. Campbell and john loxley, structural adjustment in africa hampshire. In the same year, the new government embarked on a structural adjustment programme sap which aimed to remove controls on agricultural prices, privatise over. The impact of structural adjustment on food production in zambia munacinga c h simatele abstract the paper examines the impact of selected structural adjustment policies on food production in zambia. Spending cuts could be focused on military spending. There is no reason spending cuts have to fall on the poorest sections of society. The effects of structural adjustment programs on poverty and income distribution by doris a. External debt in 2001 stood at 181% of gross national product.
1236 854 764 243 306 721 686 874 126 570 254 823 108 389 339 724 126 190 155 1020 931 879 3 145 992 984 1014 199 1389 1463 1008 690 266 733 1396 1482 1220 1473 199 1013 860 989