Feature level fusion is the higher level processing of the information to generate data with higher amount of information. The fuzzy kalman allows for the level of evidence to incorporate an uncertainty or quality measure into the report. The book emphasizes a contemporary view on the role of higher level fusion in designing crisis management systems, and provide the formal foundations, architecture and implementation strategies required for building dynamic current and future situational pictures, challenges of, and the state of the art computational approaches to designing such processes. Highlevel information fusion management and systems design. This paper presents a fusion framework based on the idea that subjectively relevant fusion could be achieved in information at higher levels of abstraction such as image edges and image segment boundaries are used to guide the basic signallevel fusion process. Designing ontologies for higher level fusion information. In lowlevel fusion, the raw data are directly provided as an input to the data fusion process. A framework for lowlevel data fusion sciencedirect. High versus lowlevel data science data science central. In this functional model, the hierarchical process of data and information fusion comprises two stages, the lowlevel fusion processes and the highlevel fusion processes. Level 0 source preprocessing level 3 threat refinement level 2 situation refinement level 1 object refinement sensors fusion database support database. Pdf incorporation of indirect evidence into an evidence. We have also developed bhattacharyya distance bd and rulebased classifiers, and have implemented these higherlevel data fusion algorithms into the czmil data processing system.
Fusion methodologies in crisis management higher level. There is little theory about the first two levels of information fusion. A trusted, unified view of customer engagement and behavior unlocks the ability to drive a better customer experience, which leads to higher retention and higher revenue per. Fusion of security system data to improve airport security. Further enhancements of the model considered additional levels, e. An international journal on multisensor, multisource information fusion. That is, each signal is first processed individually, and then fed into the fusion algorithm.
Moreover, most commercial biometric classifiers grant access to decision level information rather than score level or feature level information. The dendrogram is difficult to interpret in this case. Higher order predictions follow directly by estimating additional derivatives. If soft data such as operator reports are available, qualitative, subjective, unstructured and higherlevel information data also must be included within the framework. Hierarchical data fusion for smart healthcare springerlink. It is additionally mentioned, that the fusion has several levels that are explained separately as listed in the next section. Proceedings of the 7th world multiconference on systemics, cybernetics and informatics, 2003. Data fusion technologies produce incredibly powerful situation assessment tools with widespread military and nonmilitary applications. Highlevel information fusion is the ability of a fusion system to capture awareness and complex relations, reason over past and future events, utilize direct sensing exploitations and tacit reports, and discern the usefulness and intention of results to meet systemlevel goals. Midlevel fusion first extracts characteristics from the data before fusing them.
The technique, based upon a level 1 fusion target classification evidence accrual algorithm, uses a fuzzy kalman filter to inject new evidence into the nodes of interest to modify the level of evidence. Typically, data gathered in largescale assessments are not at the level of detail needed to diagnose individual student needs, nor are they delivered in a timely enough manner to have an impact on the learning of students tested. However, this model provides only a highlevel roadmap for data fusion, we perhaps. Other terms associ ated with data fusion that typically. Multisensor data and knowledge fusiona proposal for a.
Higher levels of fusion involve integrating the information from lower levels in order to figure out what the rel. Fusion at the decisionlevel is bandwidth efficient since only decisions, requiring a single bit, are transmitted to the fusion engine. Data fusion is the process of integrating multiple data sources to produce more consistent, accurate, and useful information than that provided by any individual data source data fusion processes are often categorized as low, intermediate, or high, depending on the processing stage at which fusion takes place. Incorporation of indirect evidence into an evidence. Application of the jdl data fusion process model for cyber. The integration of data and knowledge from several sources is known as data fusion.
There are also challenges related to creating reliable measures of higherorder skills emphasised in. A data fusion architecture for a smart healthcare ecosystem can be naturally identified by matching iot infrastructure capabilities within healthcare organisations with the existing data fusion models. Pdf high level data fusion system for cancoastwatch. Sheldon, dynamic data fusion using an ontologybased software agent system, in. Multilevel image fusion 2003 petrovic publications.
Decisionlevel fusion strategies for correlated biometric. Learning the quality of sensor data in distributed. In this sense, the term information fusion implies a higher semantic level than data fusion. Generally, data fusion could happen from raw data level such as images to the decision level. Othertermsassociated with data fusion that typically appear in the literature include decision fusion, data combination, data aggregation, multisensordata fusion,and sensor fusion. After years of intensive research that is mainly focused on lowlevel information fusion if, the focus is currently shifting towards highlevel information fusion. Midlevel fusion first subjects each data set to some kind of preprocessing such as a form of variable selection and then uses lowlevel methods to fuse the preprocessed data. An overview of some existing literature pertaining to the higher levels of fusion in the jdl df model is also provided. Less mature are level 2 processing 17, 30, situation assessment, which seeks a. Fusion of processed, higher level information to form a blueprint for fusion at. Qassam3 weapon locating radars wlr1 and wlr2 shorad radar asr mortar ew radar vehicles area near lp multisensor track formation of ram tracks. Incorporation of indirect evidence into an evidence accrual technique for higher level data fusion article pdf available in proceedings of spie the international society for optical.
Moreover, most commercial biometric classifiers grant access to decisionlevel information rather than scorelevel or featurelevel information. It involves architecturing and accessing the right summarized data usually via dashboards, excel repositories populated daily, or email alerts automatically received in your mailbox to detect anomalies or opportunities, correct problems, identify root causes, or. We will illustrate the techniques for a primitive composed of two properties, x1t and x2. One of the simplest example of feature level image fusion is region based fused. This cuttingedge book arms the fastgrowing field of fusion system developers and researchers with the essential tools and latest techniques they need to develop nextgeneration fusion services, select algorithms and software, simulate performance, and. Pdf in this paper, a goaldriven netenabled distributed data fusion system is described for cancoastwatch ccw project. The tradeoffs that accompany higherlevel data fusion effortsin terms of computing power and memory requirementswere noted. View academics in higher level data fusion on academia.
Threelevel hierarchical data fusion through the iot, edge, and. In 1993, the joint directorate laboratories jdl came up with a multilevel data fusion mod. Data fusion for low level airspace european defence agency. These characteristics can be many things, for example, a subset of the variables, a set of latent variables, or other characteristics such as shape or position in an image. Here we focus on decision level data fusion, where a sensor seeks to fuse decisions made by other sensors. In particular, decisionlevel fusion deals with the higher level aggregation of data after individual detection. Cloud data fusion can help organizations better understand their customers by breaking down data silos, including the traditional silos of online and offline profiles. Decisionlevel fusion of spatially scattered multimodal. The low level versus high level distinction was made evident in the seminal text on the subject by waltz and llinas, multisensor data fusion.
The advantages of multiplesensor data fusion projects in terms of cost, accuracy, and reliability were also discussed and contrasts were drawn with the traditional deployment of highly accurate, single sensors. High level information fusion hlif has been of considerable interest to the fusion community ever since the development of the fusion process models. However, there have been successful attempts to transform the numerical, interval and linguistic data into a single space of symmetric trapezoidal fuzzy numbers 14, 15, and. Lowlevel data fusion combines several sources of raw data to produce new raw data. Fusion at the decision level is bandwidth efficient since only decisions, requiring a single bit, are transmitted to the fusion engine. Cognitive high level information fusion leonid perlovsky. Data and information fusion dif involves a pro high. In this sense, the term information fusion implies a higher semantic level than data. Bray strategic business development sandia national laboratories p. A plethora of methods has been devised to exploit this diversity 63.
In this functional model, the hierarchical process of data and information fusion comprises two stages, the low level fusion processes and the high level fusion processes. High level sensor data fusion approaches for object recognition. The terms information fusion and data fusion are typically employed as synonyms. Image fusion, hyperspectral, gmti, elint, neural networks, data mining, information fusion, common operating picture. An initial set of challenges referring to the jdl model 1, higher. Nongaussianity is associated with diversity in higherorder statistics hos. Information fusion techniques combine data from multiple sensors, along with additional information and knowledge, to obtain better estimates of the observed. After years of intensive research that is mainly focused on low level information fusion if, the focus is currently shifting towards high level information fusion.
Level 1 on object refinement seems to have received the most attention. This paper presents some of the points the panelists plan to raise as they see them now. Higherlevel data fusion for activitybased intelligence. On exploiting lowerlevel fusion products for achieving higherlevel situational awareness j. Dasarathy proposed a sensor fusion model with three processing levels.
Applying these new algorithms to recent shoals and casi data at plymouth harbor, massachusetts, we achieved improved benthic classification accuracies over those. With backward links, fusions can take place that result in clusters at a lower distance level move from left to right. Updating ids signatures would be an example of a basic level 4 fusion process. Box 5800 albuquerque, nm 8718578 abstract data fusion has been identified by the department of defense as a critical technology for the u. The basic answer is given pretty well by quora user in this thread. In this type of fusion the extracted information from the images is integrated using complex techniques.
Less mature are level 2 processing 17, 30, situation assessment, which seeks a higher level of inference above level. A general data fusion architecture electrical and computer. Researchers in this e ld agree that the most accepted. Signal level fusion, where data correlation takes place through learning due to the lack of a mathematical model describing the phenomenon being measured. Abstract over the past decade the term fusion has become synonymous with tactical or battle space. Highlevel data fusion models each data set separately and takes all modeling results and combines these, e. The threelevel data fusion model, inspired by the taxonomies in table 2, indeed, naturally fits the classification of iot processing elements. Data fusion for low level airspace ram detection, tracking and recognition simulation scenario rockets and mortars mootw scenario mortars. High level data fusion hdf refers to the highest level of data fusion, which. Deals with decision making rather than data munging. This paper summarizes the state of the data fusion field and describes the most relevant studies.
Higherlevel fusion processes utilize fused sensor data, intelligence information, databases, maps, information on prior similar situations, preliminary assessment of the vulnerability of the area under consideration, and intent and capability of a possible adversary. Lower levels of fusion involves integrating data from multiple sensors and sources, in order to discover what entities are out there. Level 5 is the interface between the human analyst and the data fusion system. Thomopoulos posed an architecture for data fusion consisting of three modules, each integrating data at different levels or modules to integrate the data, namely. Extend traditional data fusion techniques and technology to develop products that detect, classify and track terrorist activities. High level information fusion, situation assessment, situation awareness, threat assessment. Higherlevel information fusionlevel information fusion. Highlevel information fusion in visual sensor networks.
1260 1238 710 891 251 960 1002 1452 1594 1270 149 1410 305 253 1496 1339 442 36 1323 825 589 855 1329 1506 443 292 223 1629 143 392 766 109 189 346 1275 1289 1423 1389 599 964 446